Episode 36

full
Published on:

28th Jan 2026

Faith Doesn’t Work Anymore | Infertility and Burnout

This episode examines what happens when faith stops feeling grounding and starts feeling like pressure. Stephanie Dingbaum shares her seven-year fertility journey, including the moments when hope became harder to hold than letting go, and what it cost to keep believing while the answer stayed no.

The conversation explores spiritual bypassing, burnout, and what happens when surrender stops feeling like strength and starts feeling like loss.

What This Episode Covers:

  1. Why faith can feel fake when nothing changes year after year
  2. How spiritual bypassing shows up during infertility
  3. The emotional cost of staying grateful while still waiting
  4. How burnout and nervous system overload affect desire and capacity
  5. What changed when she stopped gripping the outcome

Guest:

Stefanie Dingbaum is a therapist and podcast host who spent seven years navigating infertility before becoming a mother. Her experience reshaped how she understands faith, surrender, and trust.

Connect:

Michelle @michelleaburke

Stefanie @stefanie.dingbaum

Keywords:

faith stops working, infertility and faith, spiritual bypassing infertility, seven year fertility journey, surrender feels like giving up, why faith feels fake, burnout and infertility, nervous system and fertility, identity crisis infertility, manifesting when nothing works, hot mess magic podcast

Support Hot Mess Magic

A huge thank you to our supporters, it means a lot that you support our podcast.

If you like the podcast and want to support it, too, you can leave us a tip using the button below. We really appreciate it and it only takes a moment!
Support Hot Mess Magic
A
We haven’t had any Tips yet :( Maybe you could be the first!
Show artwork for Hot Mess Magic

About the Podcast

Hot Mess Magic
Honest conversations about the identities we build to survive and the moment they stop letting us live
You became someone to survive.

To belong. To be loved. To keep the peace, keep it together, keep going.
It worked, you’re here.

But the identity you built to get through your life started running it.

Hot Mess Magic is the conversation about the gap.

Each week Michelle Burke sits with people willing to say the true thing out loud.

Not the curated version. What’s underneath.

The patterns mistaken for personality.

The stories inherited before you could choose.

The roles played so long they stopped feeling like roles.

These are the conversations that usually stay private, about who you became, who you actually are, and the moment you realize the two no longer match.

No steps. No homework. No one here to fix you.

You were never broken.
Just the clean cut of finally hearing it named.
New episodes every Friday.
Support This Show

About your host

Profile picture for Michelle Burke

Michelle Burke